Take-Two Addresses Google AI’s Impact on Game Stocks: Project Genie Lacks Real Game Engine Capabilities

Weekly digests, stories from your favorite gaming communities, and more

You’re now subscribed

Your newsletter sign-up was successful

Want to add more newsletters?

Get your weekly dose of everything you need to know about the games you love, upcoming titles we think you’ll enjoy, and the vibrant communities that support them.

Our dedicated GTA 6 newsletter delivers breaking news, insider insights, and rumor breakdowns from the experts who know the game best.

From the minds behind Edge comes a weekly newsletter focused on the gaming industry, featuring analysis from seasoned writers, advice from industry professionals, and a glimpse into what’s coming next.

Tech enthusiasts, join our free tech newsletter for a weekly roundup of the latest innovations, the newest gadgets under review, and much more.

Subscribe to our new Switch 2 newsletter for weekly updates on Nintendo’s upcoming console, including the latest news and game recommendations.

Receive a weekly summary of the most important movie and TV news straight to your inbox. From first-look trailers to interviews and reviews, we’ve got you covered.

Get exclusive previews, competitions, and details about special events every month!

Recently, Google granted its AI Ultra subscribers access to Project Genie, a tool that allows users to create and explore AI-generated worlds. This news sent game stocks tumbling, impacting companies like Take-Two, the publisher behind GTA 6. While the company’s president acknowledges the potential of Google’s technology, he emphasizes that it cannot replace a true game engine.

“Comparing it to a game engine is just not accurate – they’re not even in the same league,” said Take-Two president Karl Slatoff during a financial call. “Genie is not a game engine.”

For anyone who has played a video game, it’s clear that Project Genie, in its current state, is far from a fully realized game. While it surpasses many previous AI-driven interactive experiences, like the unsettling Quake 2 demo from last year, its generated worlds can’t compete with those crafted by skilled developers.

Still, Slatoff finds the technology exciting. “The question is, how can it benefit our creators? I believe there will come a time when that becomes clearer. It certainly doesn’t replace the creative process.”

He acknowledges the limitations of the tool, noting that Google has recognized them as well. Currently, it focuses on world generation, which is just one aspect of game development. “Beyond world creation, there’s the storyline, emotional connection, atmosphere, and mission structure. All of those elements cannot be captured through AI, especially not through a world builder. That’s just a tiny part of what we do. If this tool proves effective, it could enhance and streamline certain components of our work.”

These realities are evident to anyone who has ever picked up a controller, but they seem lost on many investors. Following the Genie announcement, significant stock declines were reported in the gaming sector, with Unity dropping 21.6%, Roblox down 12.3%, and Take-Two falling 9%.

However, some financial analysts are advising caution, suggesting that AI tools like these won’t replace traditional game publishers. Instead, they are expected to improve development efficiency. Take-Two CEO Strauss Zelnick supports this view.

“We’re already seeing cases where generative AI tools are improving cost and time efficiency,” Zelnick stated in a recent interview, but he cautions that it’s not a cure-all – especially with GTA 6 on the way, he insists that “generative AI has no role in what Rockstar Games is creating.”

You might be better off diving into one of the best open-world games rather than exploring Project Genie.