The Evolution of Portable MP3 Players: From Popularity to Decline and Back Again

This is The Stepback, a weekly newsletter diving into a key story from the tech landscape. For insights on the rise and fall of portable media players, follow along. The Stepback lands in subscribers’ inboxes every Sunday at 8 AM ET.

How it started
We’re living in a golden age of music access, with hundreds of millions of songs at our fingertips. Yet, it wasn’t until 1998 that portable digital music truly emerged. Before that, we were hauling around CD booklets or a few cassettes in our bags. The MP3 player revolution in the early 2000s changed everything, allowing us to carry vast libraries of music—over 1,000 albums, depending on the format and device size.

The MPMan F10 is often recognized as the first commercial MP3 player, resembling an oversized pager and about the size of a deck of cards. Launched in Asia in March 1998, it barely made waves. The Diamond Rio PMP300, which hit the West in September 1998, was slightly larger and more aligned with our modern concept of a media player (think iPod). Its notoriety grew when the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) sued Diamond Multimedia to curb the spread of MP3s.

Both the F10 and PMP300 were rudimentary by today’s standards, featuring a mere 32MB of storage—enough for around 12 songs. They held less audio than a CD and often sounded inferior. However, the real challenge lay in their clunky user interfaces on tiny monochrome LCDs. Fortunately, both devices allowed for storage expansion via SmartMedia cards if you needed more space.

Eventually, some manufacturers tackled the storage issue by replacing flash memory with traditional hard drives. The Creative Nomad Jukebox, for example, boasted a 6GB drive and a design reminiscent of portable CD players, but its bulkiness—14 ounces—didn’t help its popularity.

The true golden age of portable media players began with the iPod’s launch in November 2001. By 2007, around 20% of Americans owned a personal media player. Other brands, like Microsoft and Creative, attempted to carve out their niches with Zune and Zen, respectively, but Apple’s iPod dominated, capturing over 70% of the market.

While 20% ownership isn’t universal, the iPod and the digital music revolution felt omnipresent in the 2000s. Bands like Radiohead and Nine Inch Nails experimented with pay-what-you-want digital releases, while Napster popularized terms like “file sharing” and “peer-to-peer.” Apple’s iconic ads featuring silhouettes and white earbuds were everywhere.

The personal media player’s reign was relatively brief. Although Apple didn’t fully retire the iPod lineup until 2022, it phased out the Classic model in 2014 and discontinued the Nano and Shuffle in 2017, leaving the iPod Touch—the iPhone without the phone—as the last model standing.

By 2011, it was clear that iPhone sales had surpassed iPod sales for the first time. The portable media player market quickly dwindled as smartphones replaced older devices, and music consumption shifted from buying CDs or digital downloads to streaming. What was once a $21.6 billion industry in 2008 plummeted to just $613 million by 2012, according to research.

How it’s going
Reliable figures on the current digital audio player market are hard to come by. Some research firms combine all media players, regardless of type, while others that focus on audio-specific devices can’t agree on numbers. Some claim it’s a growing $180 million industry, while others say it’s a shrinking $1.2 million market. One thing is clear: portable media players have become a niche.

For the past decade, dedicated portable music players have primarily catered to audiophiles. Brands like Sony and Astell & Kern have released high-end audio players that can exceed $3,000. Sony’s NW-A306 is the only model from either brand that approaches mainstream pricing at $399.99.

These devices are not only pricier but also more complex than the iPods of the past. They come equipped with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, large touchscreens, and high-quality digital audio converters. Many run on Android, allowing access to streaming apps like Spotify and Qobuz. Sony has fully embraced the iPod Touch model, providing its players with access to the Google Play store.

The high prices and app integration have led many to shy away from these players. Instead, those seeking an offline listening experience free from distractions have turned to vintage iPods, which still command hundreds of dollars on platforms like eBay. A thriving modding community has emerged, enhancing these devices with modern features like Bluetooth and USB-C, or simply customizing their looks.

What happens next
Despite the iPod’s popularity, the supply of functional used units will eventually dwindle. As they age, batteries will fail, and spinning drives will stop working, and most people aren’t keen on repairing delicate electronics. However, the renewed interest in iPods is driving up prices for other media players, with modders swapping new drives into Zunes and selling them for hundreds on eBay.

With Google searches for “MP3 player” nearly tripling since last year and trend pieces highlighting the iPod resurgence, several companies and startups are eager to capitalize. Chinese manufacturers have flooded online marketplaces with inexpensive players and blatant iPod knockoffs.

Successful crowdfunding campaigns, like the AP30 Music Boy, indicate a demand for retro portable music players. However, many of the available options don’t significantly improve on design or usability.

Sleevenote is one startup attempting to innovate, though its success is uncertain. Founded by musician Tom Vek, it incorporates modern conveniences like Wi-Fi syncing and Bluetooth headphones while avoiding unnecessary features like streaming or apps. It replaces traditional text lists with a grid of album art, aiming to recreate the experience of flipping through a CD booklet. It also offers limited integration with various digital music stores like Bandcamp and Qobuz.

Vek’s concept shows promise, but the bulky Day One edition has its share of issues, including subpar battery life. It’s currently sold out, and the company is unsure when more will be available.

As anti-streaming sentiment grows and the slowtech trend continues, no clear successor to the iPod has emerged in the MP3 player market.

A resurgence of the MP3 player on the scale of vinyl or CDs seems unlikely. While an iPod may offer convenience over a limited edition LP, it lacks the collectibility factor that has fueled the revival of physical media. This is evident as Gen Z and millennials buy CDs in droves, even though half of them don’t own a CD player.

By the way
* Suzanne Vega is often referred to as the “mother of the MP3.” Karlheinz Brandenburg developed audio compression technology at the Fraunhofer Society in Germany, using Vega’s “Tom’s Diner” as a benchmark due to her “warm, human voice.” James Johnston, working at Bell Labs, also used “Tom’s Diner” in his audio compression efforts. Their work led to the creation of the MPEG-1 Audio Layer III standard, known as MP3.
* Kane Kramer is credited with inventing the first digital audio player in 1979, patenting it in the UK in 1985 and the US in 1987. Many of its features, including an online music store, would later appear in the iPod and iTunes. Paul McCartney was an early financial backer, but Kramer’s IXI never reached the market. His patents lapsed in 1988, and while Apple eventually acknowledged his invention, it was largely a legal strategy to counter a patent infringement lawsuit from Burst.com.