Tim Cain, co-creator of Fallout, suggests that games could improve by embracing a toy-like approach, highlighting that titles like Minecraft and Skyrim excel in offering “freeform, goal-free play.”

Tim Cain, one of the minds behind Fallout, highlights a key distinction between toys and games, suggesting that games could enhance their appeal by incorporating more toy-like features. He points out that some of the most beloved titles, like Skyrim and Minecraft, already embrace this concept.

In a recent video, Cain elaborates on the differences between the two mediums. “A game is something you play, while a toy is something you play with,” he explains. “Games typically have rules, goals, and often a scoring system, leading to a winner or an ending.” In contrast, toys lack these structures, offering simply an object for play.

While this may seem straightforward, the conversation becomes intriguing when considering how games can function like toys. “Some games can be enjoyed as toys,” Cain notes. “Take Minecraft, for instance. Many players, myself included, approach it as a toy, focusing on building and crafting without a specific goal beyond survival. While it has objectives, most players engage with it in a freeform manner.”

Cain also shares his fondness for Skyrim, describing it as his “comfort game.” Although it features a narrative and quests, he often finds himself creating new characters and exploring the world without any particular aim. “I frequently play Skyrim as a toy, making characters without a defined goal,” he says.

He believes that many gamers share a desire for more titles that incorporate toy-like elements, even if they don’t explicitly recognize it. “The best games often include freeform, goal-free play, similar to how I enjoy Skyrim. Many players appreciate exploration that isn’t strictly quest-driven or achievement-focused. What they truly want are games with toy features.”

Whether it’s the longing for an open world to explore without being tied to a storyline or the desire for a game that remains engaging long after completing its quests, these wishes reflect a craving for toy-like elements in gaming. Cain admits he wishes he had realized this sooner.

“If I could advise my younger self, I’d say, ‘Incorporate more toy features into your games. Create more experiences that are goalless and endless,'” he reflects.

Of course, implementing these ideas requires resources, which can be a challenge for developers. Nonetheless, Cain concludes that games could greatly benefit from embracing more toy-like characteristics.

Cain recalls the intense dedication that went into creating Fallout, emphasizing that it wasn’t about crunch but rather a passion for the work.